Archive for the ‘Carnival’ category

Can You Retire Early Stuck in the Middle?

I made the comment the other day in regards to the fact that every early retirement story I’ve come across has some element of luck.  The people in question either lucked on the stock market, did well on real estate or had their own business and got bought out.  Yet that got me thinking: can you do it with no luck at all and be stuck in the middle for income?  Is it even possible to retire under 50?

So let’s try out that theory, meet my crash test case of fictitious people called Bill and Jane.  They earn between them $71,000 a year (the 2007 median salary in Canada for a two income household with kids).  So let’s break up that pay by a 60/40 split of $42,600 for one and $28, 400 for the other.  You can pick out their careers and who makes more if you want, for me I’m just assuming they get in dead end jobs and never move from this salary during their entire working career.  In actually fact they may start lower and work up, but on an inflation adjusted basis I’m assuming they are a flat line all the way.  So after tax, CPP and EI and no other deductions they clear $33,161 and $25,762 respectively, or in total $58,923 (in SK).

They are a frugal couple so they only spend $24,000/year on expenses (but not the mortgage).  On top of  that is a mortgage payment on a $250,000 home (I’m assuming they buy within their means and stick to a condo or a smaller older house in a ok location, but not a great one).  Mortgage payment for a 25 year period at 5% average rate is $690.66 twice a month assuming they bought with 5% down when they turned 22 (combination of wedding gifts and saving).  I’m assume they don’t accelerate a single payment and pay off the mortgage at 47.  I’m also assuming they pick that $28,000 as their spending rate for retirement which includes some cash for travel and fun things since the mortgage will be gone when they leave work at 47.

I’m also going to assume that having a two kids eats up any spare money until they turn 28 when they start to get serious about early retirement.  After that point, after expenses they can save at most $18,347.16 per year, but wait, who’s looking after the kids?  Let’s take off another $12,000 a year for child care, but in reality you get a tax deduction for that so let’s assume after their tax return they pay $740/month net.  So that leaves only about $789/month for saving until the kids get older, so let’s assume that lasts for 10 years.

So Bill and Jane start saving but are smart and put the money in an RRSP and reinvest the tax refund.  So that boosts their savings to about $994/month while the kids are in care.  So at 5% for 10 years that leaves them with $154,350.  Then the kids leave care and they put the extra $740 a month into savings, but let’s assume outside the RRSP.  So in total they can save $1734/month for nine more years, leaving them with $477, 741 at 47.

Now the draw that down from 47 till 65 when they get OAS and CPP at their $28,000 a year and they only get 3.5% return now.  That leaves them with only $195, 577 at 65.  So assuming a 4% safe withdrawal rate they have about $7823 from their nest egg a year, plus their CPP and OAS they should be fine in full retirement.

So in conclusion it can be done, but you have to do just everything right.  Keep you costs way down and keep your shelter costs reasonable and it can happen.  If you want to spend more than that you will need luck or hard work to make more money.

This post is now part of the 243rd edition of the Carnival of Personal Finance.

Selling Out Our Dreams

So when did you sell out on your childhood dreams?  Noticed I asked ‘when’ and not ‘if’.  Well that is because I’ve run into so very few people that are living their dreams.  What happen to us that this is so common now?

I’ll offer myself up as an example I could have chosen another path that was better in line with my creative side, but no I was practical instead and took an engineering degree.  I chose it because I knew it was a more sellable degree that offered a higher and consistent income.  Ironically I have done very little true engineering work during my career, perhaps a third of my career so far, but that doesn’t matter it still got me a steady pay cheque.

Yet why did I do it?  I think perhaps because in our society we value financial security over happiness.  Happiness is a nice ideal, but people are typically more driven to pick the choice that offers financial security.  Yet is that security an illusion.  If you don’t believe me ask any one of the thousands of auto workers that have been laid off recently.  I’m fairly sure a year ago they thought their jobs were secure.

So why do we sell out if the security isn’t there?  I think we do it because we want to take the easy way out.  We want the arrangement of show up and do your work and we send you a cheque every two weeks or twice a month.  To do what truly makes us happy would entail a lot of self examination and likely hard work to make that dream come true.  Then after all that you wouldn’t even be sure how much you would be making.  It would be a questionable investment of time for an unknown rate of return.  We would be living on what we produced and none of us is sure enough of our talent to make that bet.  Our self doubts haunt us so we take the easy way instead.

Yet how many of us are really suited for this whole slave away at a job we don’t like for pay cheque?  What would happen if more of us took a risk on happiness?  Would the world change or would every look the same except for a lot of happier people?  I don’t know.

So what’s your story?  What did you sell out for or are you one of the rare ones who are living your dreams?  If you feel like sharing, leave a comment.

The Gloom and Peak Oil

Ok I have to admit. Investing today is getting a bit more difficult. Why? It looks like the gloom is setting in over everything. News stories seem to be focusing on “X number of jobs cut”, “stock markets down”, “home sales cooling off” and my personal favorite “oil choking global economy”. It’s just a depressing kind of place where money goes into something and I actually expect it to go down further.

So what to do? Simple. Keep investing and put on your blinders to some of the noise. The media often seems to overstate the trouble of everything. For example I don’t recall a news release with an oil companies profits lately. That should cheer up some investors for a little while. At the same time if oil does keep going the way it is we would have entered the peak oil world which brings up an interesting question of if we should continue to invest they way we have.

Assuming for the minute peak oil is true as a theory (for those of you not familiar with it read this) and that it is here now or will be shortly. This would result in a rather fundamental shift of how people do business. Up until now transport was always taken for granted as being cheap. So getting something made in China where labour is cheap is possible do to cheap transportation costs. It is cheaper to do that than let someone in North America do it due to the difference in labour costs. If transportation is now more expensive that China may lose that advantage and now it makes sense to do things more locally. Why? Cheaper transport costs due to less distance traveled.

So if the shift for companies becomes local based will they get squeezed out of the local market due to more nimble small businesses which can react faster to the changing economy or will the big business world adjust to new reality of expensive transportation costs and continue to produce profits?

Overall I don’t know, but in any case a shift of some kind is likely soon. 6.5 billion people and growing population and cheap oil can’t go on forever. So what do you think? Is peak oil valid or bullshit?

This post is now part of the 161st Carnival of Personal Finance.

Carnival of Personal Finance #154

Good day all and welcome to Canadian Dream: Free at 45. My name is Tim and I’ll be your host today. In honour of my second son being born early this month I’m basing the theme of this carnival on the classic poem: Monday’s Child.

Monday’s child is fair of face (or at least wrote a great post which caught this editor’s eye).

Tuesday’s child is full of grace (perhaps owing to the fact they learned their money management and savings skills well).

Wednesday’s child is full of woe (potentially because they didn’t use their credit wisely and now have some debt).

Thursday’s child has far to go (but so does everyone who is investing for the long term).

Friday’s child is loving and giving (at least by providing a review or teaching about being frugal).

Saturday’s child works hard for a living (by looking into the economy or real estate)

But the child who is born on the Sabbath Day, Is bonny and blithe and good and gay (well with that many descriptors I think I can safely call this the misc posts section)

So that this the Carnival. Make sure to check out the main site for who is hosting next week.

PS: Sorry for the delay getting this published, but I had some sever issues this morning.

A Review of My Holiday Spending

I had a question from a reader, Jordan, about how I handle my holiday spending. By an odd twist of fate I had several of my old Christmas budget files still on my hard drive, so I in the position of being able to analyze how much I’ve spent in the last four years.

First let me explain how I handle my Christmas shopping. I plan really far in advance. We normally set our total budget amount a year in advance. That way I start saving in January for the following Christmas. Then in October I sit down with my wife and we check out our list of people we bought for last year and updated as required. We also set limits for each person at this time. Typically limits are $50 for an adult, $40 for older kids and $20 for babies.

So over the last few years our total budget has been between $1150 to $1500 for 22 to 24 people. After we buy a present we enter it into a budget spreadsheet. This allows us to track each year how under budget we are doing, since we have yet to ever break our total budget. Our actual spending has ranged from $900 to $1350 total or $40 to $56 per person including shipping.

If we go over budget on a individual present, we then reduce our spending on someone else. This way the overall budget stays below its limit regardless of what we spent on a single person.

This entire system works well for us partly because we have set limits on our spending that we don’t go over as a whole. To help you reduce your holiday bill I suggest the following:

  1. Don’t buy gifts for people you barely have a relationship with. In my mind presents for teachers, mail carriers, babysitters and office co-works is insane.
  2. If you insist on doing something for your office bring in something that everyone will like such as a sample tray of your Christmas baking.
  3. Setup a gift exchange to reduce costs. A few years back my siblings got together and setup a gift exchange between our spouses and us. The idea was to let everyone focus more on the kids. It’s worked great so far.
  4. Homemade is fine as a present. Actually when we first got married, my wife and I made gift baskets, which featured mostly homemade items such as candles, hot chocolate mix, cookies and then some assorted dollar store items like mugs. They went over very well because everyone realized the effort we put into them (not to mention our hot chocolate mix is better than any store bought one I’ve ever had).
  5. Start shopping early. This allows you a stress free week before Christmas and also allows you time to find most of your presents on a good sale. Just because a present looks like it cost $50, doesn’t mean you have to actually spend anywhere near that amount.

So that’s my method and ideas around Christmas shopping. If you have an idea that has worked for you please share.

This post is part of the Canadian Tour of Personal Finance, check out the other blog posts here.